So I have a hunch, based on scant evidence, that Zix works not because of its 5AR-1 inhibition (though I'm sure it helps), but because of its 5AR-2 inhibition, despite the study showing only around 18-20% inhibition
in-vitro.
I'm wondering if a zinc solution is simply a really good delivery mechanism for getting zinc sulfate to the dermal papilla. In other words, its efficiency is what would make it effective despite its weak inhibition, compared with say, a saw palmetto topical which might theoretically inhibit more 5AR-2 in-vitro, but maybe can't make it to the dermal papilla as easily.
I'm probably wrong, but I think its possible. I would love to see a human zix study or even a modern, targeted, in-vitro study because I still have my doubts whether zix even works