- Reaction score
- 2,041
@JaneyElizabeth Thank you for your productive, thorough, and insightful posts. You are one of the few who understands the hair loss methodology inside out.
Struggling for hair loss for 10 year now has been debilitating. I have more than 400 studies saved on my desktop. Trying to connect all the dots.
My conclusion after suffering from many painstaking trial and errors: without sufficient estrogen, you won't regrow hair!
Probably the most insightful study I came across was https://academic.oup.com/edrv/article/27/6/677/2355194. Just read the title. Hair Follicle as and Estrogen Target And Source. That explains it all.
If you further read the researchers main points you'll find that estrogen is the one primary hormone that upregulates hair growth modulators further proliferating the genes necessary for hair growth to commence.
I am talking about WNT pathway, IGF-1, FGF-7, etc.
Just to give you some perspective of my hair loss story similar to @Itsnoahkennedy, whey protein isolate was the main offender. It took me 6 years to realize this was the case.
I was taking 4 scoops of whey protein isolate for 1.5 years 5 days weekly trying to build muscle mass. It lead to diffuse thinning with major recession,
My hair loss looks like leprosy especially when it is wet. I don't recognize myself anymore in the mirror. A similar type of hair loss pattern happened to @Itsnoahkennedy and he too took whey (noah correct me if I am wrong here, but I remember you telling me this a while back).
So my question Janey is: If one simple "natural" supplement can destroy my hair because of a hormonal turbulence why can't we find a "natural" supplement that can regrow our hairs?
Have you remotely considered soy isoflavones (they have to be a specific kind of supplement not the ordinary soy milk, soy protein, or the a generic soy) with capsaicin? There was a study on this and the results do look promising.
Soy isoflavones are the closest "natural" estrogen remedy. Soy isoflavones consist of genistein and daidzein. Genistein binds to estrogen beta receptors similar to E2 and these receptors are known to influence hair growth. I am not talking about the estrogen alpha since it has no direct impact on hair growth.
Read the study I posted above if not already to better understand estrogen beta. I also have compiled a couple of noteworthy studies on soy and their effects on various receptors.
I don't mind posting those here only if you are interested.
Thanks again. You are a legend and a rockstar. We appreciate your generous and meticulous feedback. Very few people have the cognitive skillset and keen observation to fully grasp the hair anatomy. You happen to be the few.![]()
Someone messaged me yesterday about creatine causing disruption to hair. Is that similar to whey protein?
