Though those may be valid contentions in regards to the mechanisms by which those drugs operate, that is by no means the extent of the EFFECTS those drugs may have - which, is all that really matters. Finasteride's mechanism is to prevent further loss, but plenty plenty plenty of people see regrowth. Minoxidil operates in a stimulative manner, but it's actually maintained and stopped shedding on levels finasteride didn't do for me. I could care less what mechanism a drug operates so long as side effects are manageable and the results are there.Finasteride stops further loss. It isn’t a regrowth tool. Minoxidil is used for regrowth. That’s why you had that experience. Oral minoxidil also has more sides effects and it’s much more dangerous then finasteride.
Your opinion on finasteride vs. oral minoxidil is just that.... your opinion. It is dependent on the dose and individual. Said absolute claims are naive and peremptory.