- Reaction score
- 2,041
Hard Regrowth: Analog, Digital or both?
Is hair regrowth likely or not for any of us using MtF HRT meds? I see things like the following all of the time that appear to ignore the prevalence of hair regrowth while overstating the prevalence of other possible effects. I know that it says "may" related to breast growth but the following clause seems to imply a process that seems likely and extended. "Progression of baldness may slow" seems to be understating the matter:
"Within the first 6 months of therapy, there is typically a redistribution of body fat, decreased muscle mass, softening of skin, and decreased libido. Breast growth may be expected after 3 to 6 months of therapy and may continue for up to 2 years. Over a period of several years, body fat and facial hair become finer, although they are not completely eliminated by hormonal therapy alone. Progression of male pattern baldness may slow; however, hair does not typically regrow in bald areas. Many of the changes, perhaps with the exception of breast growth, are reversible with cessation of therapy".
www.sciencedirect.com
This is the article/one person study that has had a lot of influence on my thinking about hair regrowth under HRT and why it may not be linked temporally to other MtF feminization results:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
"One goal of hormone therapy for male-to-female individuals is to reduce male-pattern hair growth. Based on our clinical experience, we have long suspected that there was reversal of male pattern baldness in transgender women on treatment to a degree dependent on age and likely other factors. The case presented demonstrates that hormone therapy for male-to-female transgender patients with estrogen and spironolactone can not only reduce male-pattern hair distribution but can also reverse previous effects of androgen on scalp hair patterns".
I love the phrase "to a degree dependent on age and likely other factors". It's always the other factors that trip us up....
"We believe that the mechanism responsible for achieving scalp hair regrowth in transgender women is the suppression of testosterone to normal female levels. In our experience, this usually requires therapy with both spironolactone and estradiol. However, if transgender women treated with estrogen alone can achieve testosterone at normal female levels, we would expect to see scalp hair regrowth in these patients as well. Furthermore, it would be interesting to determine whether more scalp hair regrowth occurs over time as this patient continues hormone therapy."
So, if suppression of testosterone to normal female levels is the key, then regrowth for non-MtF's appears to be unlikely even when using AA's, reductase inhibitors and some amount of estrogen. I do not believe however, that this means that cis-males are incapable of improvement. The process is not as digital as that in my experience as I think that most if not all, tend to experience hair improvement and improvement that is apparent to others, beginning more or less from day one of the HRT process. Whether it is cosmetically significant is probably another question.
I know that achieving testosterone at normal female levels is not necessary for significant breast growth, skin effects and fat re-distribution anecdotally. Furthermore, most MtFs who see these effects notice them early on, certainly before they reach targets.
@bridgeburn seemed to have hair improvement that was easily apparent from the beginning. Since he didn't test regularly (nor do I, only four times since I started formal HRT) it would be interesting to estimate what his progressing T and E levels were as he went along. So the situation regarding hair regrowth via the anecdotal experience of the thread's founder appears to be far more benevolent then how stated in the study, which presented matters in a more digital, not analog fashion. If this involves gene expression then which is it? Do we have to hit target T to initiate things or are there also more minor persistent triggering mechanisms going on?
I will try to submit for testing this week to see where I stand.
Is hair regrowth likely or not for any of us using MtF HRT meds? I see things like the following all of the time that appear to ignore the prevalence of hair regrowth while overstating the prevalence of other possible effects. I know that it says "may" related to breast growth but the following clause seems to imply a process that seems likely and extended. "Progression of baldness may slow" seems to be understating the matter:
"Within the first 6 months of therapy, there is typically a redistribution of body fat, decreased muscle mass, softening of skin, and decreased libido. Breast growth may be expected after 3 to 6 months of therapy and may continue for up to 2 years. Over a period of several years, body fat and facial hair become finer, although they are not completely eliminated by hormonal therapy alone. Progression of male pattern baldness may slow; however, hair does not typically regrow in bald areas. Many of the changes, perhaps with the exception of breast growth, are reversible with cessation of therapy".
Androgen Suppression - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
This is the article/one person study that has had a lot of influence on my thinking about hair regrowth under HRT and why it may not be linked temporally to other MtF feminization results:
Scalp Hair Regrowth in Hormone-Treated Transgender Woman - PMC
Evidence of androgenetic alopecia, or male pattern baldness, can be distressing for transgender women. Here we present the case of a transgender woman with scalp hair regrowth after ∼6 months on oral estradiol and spironolactone therapy achieving ...
"One goal of hormone therapy for male-to-female individuals is to reduce male-pattern hair growth. Based on our clinical experience, we have long suspected that there was reversal of male pattern baldness in transgender women on treatment to a degree dependent on age and likely other factors. The case presented demonstrates that hormone therapy for male-to-female transgender patients with estrogen and spironolactone can not only reduce male-pattern hair distribution but can also reverse previous effects of androgen on scalp hair patterns".
I love the phrase "to a degree dependent on age and likely other factors". It's always the other factors that trip us up....
"We believe that the mechanism responsible for achieving scalp hair regrowth in transgender women is the suppression of testosterone to normal female levels. In our experience, this usually requires therapy with both spironolactone and estradiol. However, if transgender women treated with estrogen alone can achieve testosterone at normal female levels, we would expect to see scalp hair regrowth in these patients as well. Furthermore, it would be interesting to determine whether more scalp hair regrowth occurs over time as this patient continues hormone therapy."
So, if suppression of testosterone to normal female levels is the key, then regrowth for non-MtF's appears to be unlikely even when using AA's, reductase inhibitors and some amount of estrogen. I do not believe however, that this means that cis-males are incapable of improvement. The process is not as digital as that in my experience as I think that most if not all, tend to experience hair improvement and improvement that is apparent to others, beginning more or less from day one of the HRT process. Whether it is cosmetically significant is probably another question.
I know that achieving testosterone at normal female levels is not necessary for significant breast growth, skin effects and fat re-distribution anecdotally. Furthermore, most MtFs who see these effects notice them early on, certainly before they reach targets.
@bridgeburn seemed to have hair improvement that was easily apparent from the beginning. Since he didn't test regularly (nor do I, only four times since I started formal HRT) it would be interesting to estimate what his progressing T and E levels were as he went along. So the situation regarding hair regrowth via the anecdotal experience of the thread's founder appears to be far more benevolent then how stated in the study, which presented matters in a more digital, not analog fashion. If this involves gene expression then which is it? Do we have to hit target T to initiate things or are there also more minor persistent triggering mechanisms going on?
I will try to submit for testing this week to see where I stand.
Last edited:
