Is this Doctor kidding?

chewbaca

Experienced Member
Reaction score
1
Winston Tongco asked: "Hello! Please help me with my inquiries. It is proven that both type 1 & 2 of the enzyme 5-Alpha Reductase (5-AR) converts testosterone in men into DHT which is the culprit of male pattern baldness (male pattern baldness.) I have heard that some medications such as minoxidil and propecia blocks off type 2 of this enzyme successfully for the treatment of the vertex part only and that the anterior (frontal) is poorly restored. If it is true that some medications blocks off both types 1 & 2 and are successful for the treatement of both anterior and the vertex, So if the 5-AR enzyme that is converted to DHT and that DHT alone causes male pattern baldness for both anterior and the vertex, then is it logical to think that there are also 2 types of DHT? Thanks. Winston Tongco "

Dr Peter H. Proctor, PhD MD answered: "Your question requires too detailed an explaination to explain easily. As far as anyone knows, minoxidil has no effect on DHT, the most important, but not the only, androgen in pattern hair loss. Also, medical treatment works in front, just not as well as in the back. There are two different 5-AR, but it appears that the Type-2 enzyme is not of much importance in balding. Peter H Proctor, PhD,MD
http://www.drproctor.com............ Dr Proctor"

http://www.hairlosshelp.com/qna/Detail.Cfm?FAQID=9410&ExpertID=1
 

Freestyle

Established Member
Reaction score
0
A typo maybe? Too many late nights for Proctor?

I'm pretty sure he meant to say that Type I's effects on hair loss are questionable.
 

Bryan

Senior Member
Staff member
Reaction score
43
Freestyle said:
I'm pretty sure he meant to say that Type I's effects on hair loss are questionable.

Agreed.
 

Old Baldy

Senior Member
Reaction score
1
It was a typo.

Peter H. Proctor
May 8 1998, 2:00 am show options

Newsgroups: alt.baldspot
From: pproc...@neosoft.com (Peter H. Proctor) - Find messages by this author
Date: 1998/05/08
Subject: Re: Type I or type II? Dr. P.?
Reply to Author | Forward | Print | Individual Message | Show original | Report Abuse



In article <6iv5md$50...@nnrp1.dejanews.com> gs06...@panther.gsu.edu writes:
>From: gs06...@panther.gsu.edu
>Subject: Type I or type II? Dr. P.?
>Date: Fri, 08 May 1998 14:43:24 GMT
>O.k. I'm really curious about gettin resolved this:
>Do Type I and II both play role in hair loss?
>If so, what kind of stuff acts on Type II alone (besides
>finasteride). ?? Any, herbs, medicine, whatever?
>So, green tea, GLA, and S.Palmetto don't do crap for my hair?
>Anybody?
>Help people. It will be appreciated.
>p.s. Thanx Dr. P for sticking with us.


Type 2 seems to be the most important one. Remember, the dose-response
curve for antiandrogens is almost flat. Even a relatively weak one like
Finasteride is probably almost as good as castration.

Dr. P
 
Top