I'll chime in now that I've tried both products you've mentioned. For me personally, I definitely prefer the Fish putty. It thickens up your hair nicely and is much easier to work with than the Got2B Chaotic putty. The Got2B is just very difficult to work with for some reason - it's almost like it thickens your hair too much and makes it a poofy mess. Plus it's too dulling and you can definitely tell you have product in your hair. With the Fish putty it gives you a nice matte finish without looking like you have any product in. In fact, when I got my hair cut yesterday my hairdresser had to ask if I had any product in my hair because she couldn't tell by looking. The one bad thing about the Fish putty is that it's really thick so it's hard to spread in your hands - you just have to work it a bit. Once you have it spread in your hands, just add a tiny bit of water to make it a little easier to apply to your dry hair and you're good to go. It lets you do anything you want with your hair and provides all day hold that's reworkable. Also, it smells great and washes out easily. I definitey recommend it.
