Hi Ive been on propecia for 16.5 months. regaine for 11 months....I didnt notice any change apart from the temples receiding slowly (there still NW1 1.5) my hair thinned on propecia for 11months....thickened up a little then the last 3/4 months is thinning again on top...the scalp is visibe and the middleline down the hair(centre) is so thin and wispy.....Is propecia not working. Im hoping on the stories where peoples hair have got thicker from 19 months / 2 years. 
