i hear you
i was on liquid (as well as propecia and tricomin) for many years. basically good for maintaining hair, but last year started to lose ground.
i switched from liquid to foam in morning, liquid at night on Nov. 19. experienced a bad shed.
then in Feb i switched to foam in morning AND evening, then added spectral DNC right before bed. so 3x a day application (if anybody knows for sure if 3x is a bad thing, let me know, please)
now my hairline looks the worst its ever been. i do see lots o' tiny hairs right now, which is giving me some fresh hope, but most of them are a few milimeters behind my current hairline, so wondering if that means further recession
at the end of the day, i don't have verdict on the foam. but i'm sticking with it because (1) it's only been 3.5 months, which really isn't enough time for a firm verdict and (2) most of that time i was mixing it up with foam and liqud, which might muddy things