It seems greater success reported with the FOAM on this site

[JWM]

If you check other hair loss sites, most people state disasterous results with the foam. Yet here on HairLossTalk.com it seems to gather a more positive response.

Can anyone here say they are uhappy with the foam?

 

[JWM]

Something else I noticed. Those with the best results on the foam were NOT previous liquid users.

 

[Cassin]

Something else I noticed. Those with the best results on the foam were NOT previous liquid users.

Not true.

I used liquid for a long time. and in fact I use both.

This forum preaches patience...maybe that has something to do with it.

 

[beaner]

I used liquid from 2002-2006 and switched to the foam and believe it's better. I use the liquid once in a while, but my preference is the foam without a doubt.

 

[Pereira]

Ok, I'm the black sheep. I was on liquid with great sucess, switch to foam and hair gone. So back to the liquid. :$

 

[JWM]

Beaner

Are you using Foam in the a.m. and liquid in the p.m.?

 

[masculineyourheart]

I like using the liquid because it's easier to add stuff to it. More room to evolve on it than the ol' foamy.

 

[beaner]

Beaner

Are you using Foam in the a.m. and liquid in the p.m.?

Yes..that's what I've been doing lately just to use up the liquid I have. When the liquid is gone, I'll probably go back to foam twice a day, but who knows---I may get some more liquid to save a buck or two since it's so dirt cheap.

 

[Private Ryan]

use both before. i believe they are about the same. both does nothing much for me yet didn't suffer from any side effect.

change back to liquid as it is easier to add stuff to it. i just wish i am not allegy to PPG so i don't have to get from Dr. Lee. his stuffs is expensive.

 

[ginger-uk]

I switched from Regaine liquid to Rogaine Foam and my hair is getting worse. I will be switching back asap. Do people go for Kirkland or Rogaine?

 

[Hans Gruber]

Something else I noticed. Those with the best results on the foam were NOT previous liquid users.

Not true.

I used liquid for a long time. and in fact I use both.

This forum preaches patience...maybe that has something to do with it.

:agree:

 

[treeshrew]

i've been using foam 1 app/day on the hairline for 4 months. no shed. very minimal growth (a few hairs) but i feel it's maintaining the hairline.

 

[zxAddict]

Only ever used liquid (Dr Lee's) and that works fine. Maybe foam would work better, maybe not- but I'm not about to risk the switch when things are fine the way they are. For now anyways.

 

[ginger-uk]

Man you have some serious stuff in your regimen. I was slowly loosing out to liquid. I switched to foam at the same time as I started finasteride. Initially I was comfortable with the hair, but recently the temples have started to go bad (7 or 8 months). I am thinking about switching back to liquid and staying on finasteride and see if it picks up.... :lost:

 

[zxAddict]

Man you have some serious stuff in your regimen. I was slowly loosing out to liquid. I switched to foam at the same time as I started finasteride. Initially I was comfortable with the hair, but recently the temples have started to go bad (7 or 8 months). I am thinking about switching back to liquid and staying on finasteride and see if it picks up.... :lost:

If you were slowly loosing to liquid minoxidil then discontinuing minoxidil will mean you loose even faster. You haven't discontinued minoxidil but the foam may not be as effective for you for whatever reason. I'd go back to liquid and add in something else like spironolactone/revivogen/Super Zix (minus the zinc component).

 

[ginger-uk]

I think I am going to go back to liquid tbh. I don't want to go onto revivogen, I've heard mixed reviews about spironolactone, and I have no idea what the other product is?!

I wish Hairloss would update their shop, there top 5 products seem not to reflect the general concious of the forum?!