For a product claimed to be "completely ineffective".....

[beaner]

It seems to be working quite well for the below folks taken from our success stories forum over the last couple of months, and there are many more, but I don't have time to look. I'll chose this "completely ineffective" product any day of the week over a greasy mess.


viewtopic.php?f=30&t=38337&p=412379&hilit=+foam#p412379

viewtopic.php?f=30&t=40910&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&hilit=foam

viewtopic.php?f=30&t=41383&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&hilit=foam

viewtopic.php?f=30&t=35896&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&hilit=foam

 

[philly]

...

 

[beaner]

Pictures speak a thousand words. How is that antecdotal?And those without pictures, do you think they are imagining their success? Like I said, there are plenty more of those posts with pictures if you care to have a look. By using the terminology "completely ineffective" you are wrong. There may be a study showing that it is "less" effective, but like I said it works better for ME as well as others regardless of a 4 month study.

I rest my case Philly. No hard feelings.

Actually, no I haven't read the study yet. I got a bunch of pop-ups when I opened that page so I won't open it while on my work pc. I'll get to it. Thanks for sending the link.

 

[philly]

...

 

[beaner]

PM me when you've read it. Don't thank me, thank Tallinn for uploading it.

I will. Here's another interesting pic of a foam user

viewtopic.php?f=30&t=44184&p=417064#p417064

 

[JWM]

I think what we need is a long time liquid user who was starting to lose ground, post about how the foam brought him back up to par.

IMO, those who START with the foam are getting a great initial response from minoxidil as many do, but those of us who have been on minoxidil for ten years or so (pathetic people like me) will struggle to find anything to help them improve in the minoxidil department.

 

[beaner]

I think what we need is a long time liquid user who was starting to lose ground, post about how the foam brought him back up to par.

IMO, those who START with the foam are getting a great initial response from minoxidil as many do, but those of us who have been on minoxidil for ten years or so (pathetic people like me) will struggle to find anything to help them improve in the minoxidil department.

I was using the liquid for over 4 years before starting the foam, and then results improved. This is why I believe the foam to be more effective for me and most certainly not "completely ineffective" (translation: doesn't work). If that were the case I would have lost considerable ground after 4 years of minoxidil use.

My whole point to this post is to show that one cannot claim the foam doesn't work, when it very clearly does. The liquid may work better for some, who am I to say it doesn't, but the foam also works just as well for many.